I am a huge fan of MAC Paint Pots. I use Painterly every single day as my base before shadow and I feel like it holds up really well. I do not have oily eyelids so I can’t tell you how these would work if you do. I only own 3 shades, Painterly, Indianwood (antique brown) and Perky (soft pink). I had heard claims that these dry out quickly but in my experience I have had them for quite some time and there’s not even a sign of it drying up. I have gone through an entire Painterly with no drying. These are honestly what I turn to when I am doing a quick make up look and running out the door. It takes no time to swipe these on and they blend so easily. They are super creamy with wonderful colour pay off. Coming in at $25 a pop, they are on the more expensive side – with Maybelline Colour Tattoos at a fraction of the price. In saying that, in MY opinion, these are totally worth it. I hope to expand my Paint Pot collection in the future and I recommend you add at least 1 to yours!